Paying Off $60K of Debt in a Year — with 2 Babies? How This Couple Did It

Get out of debt
Cort and Katelyn Pinnock pose at Salt Lake Comic Con in 2016. Photo courtesy Katelyn Pincock

“We want to move up in life. We want to have our kids have a good start, and we want to set a good example. We just thought if we want to be a good example, we need to get going on it and be debt-free.”

Together with her husband Cort, Katelyn Pincock paid off nearly $60,000 in student loans, credit card debt, medical bills and more — in just one year.

I spoke with the mother of two the week they made their final debt payment, as the family was moving into their new house in Idaho Falls, Idaho.

Deciding to Get Out of Debt

Get out of debt
Cort and Katelyn Pincock paid off nearly $60,000 in student loans, credit card debt, medical bills and more in just one year.

As a wedding gift five years ago, the couple received a book by Dave Ramsey, and about two years ago began listening to the finance guru’s podcast. The lessons they were learning gave them the push they needed to take their finances seriously.

The two were sitting on substantial debt. Each was still paying off student loans. They shared credit card and medical debt from the birth of their children. And they needed to repay a family member for a $10,000 loan.

In September 2015, the couple set a goal to be debt-free (except for their mortgage) within a year. Twelve months later, in September 2016, they had paid down $60,000 in debt.

How did they do it?

“My husband, he actually was working three jobs the last year,” Katelyn explains.

Cort was working full-time for a health and wellness company when they set their debt-free goal. Throughout the year, he worked about 20 hours a week overtime for a total $42,000 annual salary.

Around the same time they set their goal, he took a second job teaching math and science at a local community college. He taught three nights a week from 7 to 9 p.m. and made around $400 a month.

In addition to teaching, he sometimes tutored after hours at the college, plus tutored kids independently at home for an hour or two a couple days a week. The independent tutoring brought in another $150 a month.

Over the summer of 2016, Cort landed a new job with a significant pay increase — more than $1,600 a month. The bump brought them to a $62,000 annual salary and gave their debt pay-off a nice boost in its final weeks.

But the couple didn’t rely on his income alone to achieve their goal. Cort’s two side gigs may seem like a lot already, but that’s just the beginning.

Making Extra Money on the Side

Cort and Katelyn Pinnock hold their Healthy Wage checks.
Cort and Katelyn Pinnock hold their HealthyWage checks.

“We’ve been doing Amazon for a few years, but we kind of upped it when we started paying off debt,” Katelyn says.

They buy items like game systems and textbooks to resell through Fulfillment by Amazon. They were bringing in an extra $200 a month through FBA, but have slowed significantly during their move.

In search of even more creative ways to make money, the couple learned about HealthyWage from The Penny Hoarder (thanks for reading!).

HealthyWage lets users bet on their own weight loss to gain motivation to achieve a goal weight — and win money when they do.

Katelyn and Cort each bet $75 per month for six months — she wanted to lose 40 pounds, while he wanted to lose 60. Both reached their goals, landing another $3,000 to put toward their family’s debt.

Katelyn considers herself, above all, a stay-at-home mom. But the title is deceiving. While she doesn’t work full time, this mom has found plenty of lucrative ways to fill her time.

“You know, it’s just crazy what money is out there if you’re willing to (work for it),” she says.

She’s a painter and a crafter, and has found some creative ways to make money from her skills. She paints commissioned murals for individuals and creates promotional art for businesses.

One of Katelyn Pinnock's holiday window paintings.
One of Katelyn Pincock’s holiday window paintings.

For example, her main client right now is a local A&W. Every few months, she paints a promotion on the fast food restaurant’s window, “like a huge root beer and fries.” Over the holidays, she’ll decorate the windows with Santa and snowmen.

Katelyn also sells her creations at local farmers markets — her most popular items are magic wands!

“My family and I went to Comic-Con last year,” she told me. “We all wanted to be Harry Potter, and so we were looking to buy magic wands. Everything was really expensive, and so I put together my own little way of doing it and my own little spin on them. Now they’re one of my most popular selling items. I get custom orders all the time.”

Katelyn Pincock's handmade wands.
Katelyn Pincock’s handmade magic wands.

She sells the wands to kids at the farmers markets and on Etsy for $20 apiece. She’s working on a contract with a local gas station convenience store to sell them there, as well.

She’s excited to see the business grow, particularly since debt repayment is off their plate, freeing her to think about putting money into promotion. It’s been growing pretty well through word-of-mouth already — from about $1,000 in sales her first year to $5,000 so far this year.

“Just in that one year of time — word of mouth — that’s how much it’s grown,” she explains. “I can only imagine next year where I’ll be.”

The business only costs her about $100 a month, which covers materials and occasional fees to sell at a market.

“It’s funny, I’ve made more doing that this year than I did working part time all of last year,” Katelyn recalls of the two days a week she’d work retail. She’s earning more money and putting in far fewer hours selling her artwork.

Saving Money and Sticking to a Budget

The Pincocks’ kids are 1 and 2 years old now. Katelyn has them at home full time, save for a couple days a month if she’s painting for a business.

Other than that, she gets her work done during naptime.

With his busy schedule, Cort is out the door by 6 a.m. most mornings and not home until after 7 p.m. — 9 p.m. if he’s tutoring.

To manage time and save money over the past year, Katelyn worked through their food storage to cut back on the grocery bill.

“A lot of days were spent in the garden,” she says. “We tried not to go shopping. We wouldn’t go out a lot. We’d just do what we could to save money.”

They used the budgeting app EveryDollar to stick to a strict budget. Every day, “we would sit down and look at our budget, where we were at, what we had left.”

They cut back some on shopping, opting for consignment stores for clothes instead of the mall. Katelyn says they’ll probably stick with the habit, even now that their debt is paid off.

“I don’t feel like my life has suffered from not shopping at the mall,” she says.

Tightening their budget made room for even more money to put toward paying down their debt.

With the sale of their house, the Pincocks were able to pay off their $10,000 personal loan and a remaining $4,000 in student loan debt. They reached their goal in September 2016.

What to Do Next

Out from under massive debt, this family is not slowing down.

They bought the new house for the family, and also have enough saved to make a down payment on an investment property.

“We’re pretty excited,” Katelyn told me. “We really want to start investing in real estate to grow that income every month.”

Their goal is to make enough extra income to cover their mortgage, plus an extra $300 a month per rental property as they grow yet another business together.

“We bought our previous house as a short sale, and we put a ton of hours into fixing that up,” Katelyn explains. “We painted every single inch of that house and redid the bathrooms and the floors. Everything was brand new when we left, so we were able to get the return that we got.”

They plan to do the same with their new house.

“It is a little bit of a fixer-upper, and in two years, we hope to turn around and get that same return. Yeah, it’s a bigger, nicer house (than the first one), but we have a plan with it.”

I asked Katelyn if they’re taking a break to catch their breath after working so hard for a year to achieve their major financial milestone.

“I mean, I have a huge window-painting job tomorrow morning,” she replied. “I have a custom wand I’m working on right now, and it’s still coming in.”

In short, they continue to look forward. We’re excited to see what they can achieve in another year!

Your Turn: How have you paid down a large amount of debt?

Dana Sitar (@danasitar) is a staff writer at The Penny Hoarder. She’s written for Huffington Post,, Writer’s Digest and more, attempting humor wherever it’s allowed (and sometimes where it’s not).