Here Are the Best Car Insurance Companies of 2023
Car ownership comes with unseen costs. Everyone’s least favorite: the dreaded insurance.
Car insurance companies often get a bad rap, partially thanks to reviews from disgruntled customers. That makes it hard to determine the best auto insurance for you.
What does “best” car insurance company even mean?
The answer differs widely from consumer to consumer. If saving money is your biggest concern, you’ll probably value cheaper premiums over all else. If you’ve had bad experiences with customer service, you’ll want a company known for its superior service and reliability.
You may also want to consider other factors, like whether an insurer covers drivers with poor records or offers discounts for teen drivers with good grades.
Looking for a new policy? Compare your options by using a website called EverQuote. Answer a few questions and within minutes, you could save up to $610 a year.
Best Car Insurance on a Budget
Auto insurance rates depend on a variety of factors, including your age, location and driving track record. Therefore, the cheapest car insurance varies from driver to driver.
Here’s a list of companies offering budget-friendly car insurance. All prices reflect minimum liability coverage.
Erie Insurance Group
You might not have heard of Erie Insurance Group. That’s because, as of February 2023, it’s only available in 12 states plus the District of Columbia. But compared to other insurers, Erie’s rates tend to be lower, particularly in Pennsylvania and Virginia.
In addition to offering competitive rates, Erie Insurance Group ranked at number three in the 2022 J.D. Power U.S. Auto Claims Satisfaction Study.
If you live in Wisconsin, Illinois, Ohio, Indiana, Kentucky, Tennessee, Pennsylvania, West Virginia, Virginia, North Carolina, Maryland, D.C. or New York, check out Erie to see if you could save money.
Average Rate: $39 per month
State Farm
No matter which state you live in, you can likely get an auto insurance policy from State Farm. A car insurance policy from State Farm costs about 29% lower than the national average, making it a great budget pick for homeowners across the country.
In addition to low premiums, State Farm has a variety of discounts, ranging from policy bundling to safe driving. This can help you score an even lower car insurance rate, giving you more flexibility in your budget to spend or save.
Average Rate: $41 per month
Geico
You probably know Geico from those commercials with the annoying British gecko. But that gecko’s claim about saving you 15% or more on car insurance could be true.
Geico is the second largest insurer in the U.S. and is available in all 50 states. Of those states, drivers in New York and Utah could save the most with Geico.
Average Rate: $52 per month
Best Car Insurance Customer Service
Customer satisfaction is measured by many factors. To determine the most reliable car insurance company, we turned to the aforementioned J.D. Power U.S. Claims Satisfaction Study.
The study rates insurance companies based on seven categories: repair process, overall satisfaction, the initial claims reporting process, getting an estimate, rental experience, claims servicing and settlement.
Here are the top three, in order:
Amica Mutual
Amica Mutual, which is available in 49 states (excluding Hawaii), ranked as the top auto insurance company in the 2022 J.D. Power study. Amica has relatively positive customer ratings on sites like Consumer Affairs and responds to negative reviews with the aim of making the customer’s experience right.
Overall Satisfaction: 5/5
NJM Insurance Co.
Coming in second in the J.D. Power study is NJM, also known as New Jersey Mutual. The company sells auto insurance in five states: New Jersey, Pennsylvania, Connecticut, Maryland, and Ohio.
Overall Satisfaction: 5/5
Erie Insurance Group
Budget-friendly Erie Insurance came third in the J.D. Power study. Erie Insurance is rated relatively well by its policyholders, and customers have several ways to contact customer care, including online chat, email, phone and in-person.
Overall Satisfaction: 5/5
Best Car Insurance for Teens
Teen drivers typically find it hard to get affordable insurance. A new driver’s lack of experience and maturity places a black mark on them, leading to higher premiums. But there is hope out there for young drivers looking for decent insurance coverage at an affordable price.
State Farm
State Farm offers a variety of discounts for young drivers. The Good Student Discount offers discounts of up to 25% for drivers under 25 who maintain good grades in school. You can also get a driver training discount for taking driver’s ed classes.
The Steer Clear safe driver discount uses an app to record your trips, and you can also watch safe driving videos and take quizzes.
Erie Insurance Group
Erie Insurance offers several discounts designed to help lower the cost of insurance for young drivers:
- The Youthful Driver Discount is for unmarried drivers under 21 who live at home.
- The Youthful Longevity Discount is designed for drivers who spend multiple years in a row under an Erie policy, whether their own or their parents’.
- Finally, the Driver Training Discount gives cheaper rates — discounts range from 5% to 20% — to drivers under 21 who complete an accredited driver training course.
American Family
American Family offers a Teen Safe Driver program that can net you a nice discount on your premiums. The program uses an app to track driving behavior and suggest ways you can become safer behind the wheel.
After 3,000 miles or one year in the program, you’ll get a 10% discount on your insurance premium.
Best Car Insurance for a Bad Driving Record
If you have a bad driving record, chances are you find it hard to get affordable car insurance. But don’t despair: Some auto insurance providers do offer affordable policies even to bad drivers.
State Farm
If you have a history of speeding or auto accidents, State Farm may have an affordable car insurance policy for you. The following are State Farm’s premiums for drivers with various dings on their record:
- Ticket: $110 per month
- Accident: $125 per month
- DUI: $227
Erie Insurance Group
Although its coverage area is fairly limited, Erie Insurance Group offers very favorable rates for drivers with a poor driving record — in particular, those who have a DUI on their record. Average monthly costs are as follows:
- Ticket: $112
- Accident: $128
- DUI: $169
American Family
Like Erie Insurance, AmFam has a relatively limited coverage area but could be a good pick if you are eligible for coverage. The average monthly rates with AmFam are below:
- Ticket: $168
- Accident: $214
- DUI: $229
Top Car Insurance Companies Compared
| Insurance Company | Average Monthly Premium* | Good Student Discount | Safe Driving Discount | Car Safety Equipment Discount |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Erie | $39 | No | Yes | Yes |
| Geico | $52 | Up to 15% | Up to 26% | Yes |
| USAA | $31 | Yes | Yes | Not specified |
| Amica Mutual | $92 | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| American Family | $53 | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Allstate | $79 | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| State Farm | $41 | Up to 25% | Yes | Yes |
| Progressive | $63 | Yes | Yes | Not specified |
| Nationwide | $69 | Yes | Yes | Yes |
*Average monthly premium rates were determined by ValuePenguin.com, which obtained quotes from the largest car insurance companies based on the example of a 30-year-old male driver.
How to Choose the Best Car Insurance Company For You
Consumer Reports recommends shopping around to get the best deal, even if you already have insurance. Doing so will show you the variety of available options so you can make the best decision based on your needs and budget.
Your best bet is to get in touch with the company and ask some questions pertaining to your situation. Here are a few important questions to get you started.
What Types of Claims Are Covered?
The minimum mandatory coverage varies depending on where you live. The first place to check is your state insurance commissioner’s website to see those minimum requirements. For example, in Ohio, where I live, only liability insurance is required by law.
But you might choose to buy more than the minimum requirement to more fully protect yourself and your assets.
Ask your insurance agent what they cover. If you stick with basic liability insurance, read the fine print to see the types of claims it covers. Ditto if you add physical damage coverage or anything above and beyond the minimum.
What Is Excluded?
Just as you need to know what’s covered, you should know what’s excluded. For example, some policies may not cover you if you’re in a collision with an uninsured driver, if you’re a victim of vehicle theft, if you collide with an animal or if your car is damaged in a natural disaster.
Ask for a list of what’s not covered to determine the likelihood that these exclusions will affect you. For example, if you live in an area prone to hurricanes, you’ll want to ensure your car is covered for natural disasters. If you often drive on country roads, you’ll probably want to be covered if you hit a deer.
Can I Choose Who Performs Repairs?
When your car sustains damage, some insurance companies will choose the auto repair shop that will fix your car. This is usually due to an agreement between the repair shop and the insurance company, where the shop cuts the insurance company a deal for sending customers their way.
Usually, this works fine, but if you have a preferred mechanic, you might not appreciate being told where to get your car fixed. Or, if you have a high deductible, you might want to get a second opinion on the price before committing to a repair order.
What Are the Costs?
With any insurance plan, the most notable costs are the monthly premiums. But your deductible could cause serious financial issues in case of an accident.
A high deductible means you’ll need to pay more out of pocket for a repair before your insurance policy kicks in and covers the rest. If you have enough savings, you could get away with a higher deductible and lower monthly premium. But if your safety net is lacking, opting for a lower deductible and higher premiums could be a smarter choice.
What Additional Coverage Is Offered?
Liability insurance typically only covers damage to other people or property when you’re at fault. Under liability insurance, paying to repair your own car could be on you. For that reason, you might consider additional coverage to help cover you in various scenarios.
Comprehensive coverage protects you in cases where your car is damaged by an event other than an accident, like an act of Mother Nature.
Collision coverage pays to repair your car after an accident, typically whether or not the accident was your fault.
Uninsured motorist protection covers you when you’re in an accident with a driver who doesn’t have insurance. Without this type of protection, you would be liable for any damage to your vehicle, which could cost you big.
Personal injury protection, also called “no-fault” coverage, helps pay for medical and other costs no matter whose fault the accident was. It can also cover things like lost wages and transportation to medical appointments. Some states mandate this type of coverage, while in others, it’s an optional add-on.
How to Save Money on Car Insurance
You have multiple ways to ensure you’re getting the best rate on your car insurance, no matter which company you choose.
Bundle Your Insurance
It pays to go with the same company for all your insurance needs. Most insurance companies offer discounted rates when you bundle things like home, auto and personal property insurance.
Drive Safely
It can pay to be a responsible driver. Most insurance companies lower your rates the longer you go without an accident. Others use technology like apps to measure your driving behavior and offer a discount for using the app to become a better driver.
Pay in Full
You might get a discount by paying your annual car insurance premium in full. It’s worth considering if you have enough savings and want to spend less overall on car insurance. If you can’t afford to pay in full, ask if you can get a discount for enrolling in an auto-pay program.
Driver Training
Many insurance companies will offer a discount if you complete driver training courses, regardless of your age.
Car Safety Equipment
Things like anti-theft devices, airbags and safety technology found in new cars could get you a discount. Make sure you mention these when getting a quote.
Choosing the right car insurance policy can be a stressful experience, but it pays to shop around and consider all your options before signing on the dotted line.
Catherine Hiles lives in Ohio with her husband and their two children. By day she manages a team of writers and graphic designers, and catches up on her own writing in her spare time.
