The Cracks In HOA Communities No One Talks About
What appears to be community upkeep can sometimes feel more like corporate bureaucracy. HOAs were supposed to protect neighborhoods, yet frustrations are rising among those footing the bill. Let’s break down 15 common failures that show how the system is shifting and who’s bearing the cost.
Rising Fees
You’d think those rising dues mean better services, right? Instead, many homeowners are seeing vague budget lines, surprise special assessments and no clear explanation. A 2022 survey by HomeAdvisor found nearly 40% of HOA residents didn’t know where their fees were going. That uncertainty adds up to distrust.
More From The Penny Hoarder: The Dumbest Things We Keep Spending Too Much Money On
Poor Financial Management
Sometimes, the warning signs come late: an emergency fund already drained or a major project suddenly underfunded. Boards often lack financial training, and embezzlement does happen. For example, in 2023, Arizona’s Auditor General exposed millions mishandled by HOAs statewide.
Make money easier. Sign up for The Penny Hoarder’s newsletter today.
Inconsistent Rule Enforcement
When two homes violate the same rule but only one gets fined, something’s off. HOAs that pick and choose what to enforce create a power imbalance. That’s unfair and actionable. Legal experts warn that this pattern fuels lawsuits and undermines the entire governance model.
More From The Penny Hoarder: If You Have More Than $1,000 in Your Checking Account, Make These Money Moves
Rental Rules That Restrict Homeowners
Homeowners looking to rent their property sometimes hit roadblocks in HOA communities. Some boards enforce strict limits on how many units can be leased, and others prohibit short-term or vacation stays entirely. These tight rules leave little room for flexibility, especially for owners relying on rental income or temporary relocation.
More From The Penny Hoarder: The Best Rewards Credit Cards to Maximize Your Spending in 2025
Restrictions On Property Modifications
Many HOAs set firm rules on home changes—banning specific paint colors, fences or solar panels. These restrictions can frustrate owners who want to customize their property. However, some states now protect eco-friendly updates, challenging HOA power and giving homeowners more freedom over their own homes.
More From The Penny Hoarder: Our Picks for The Best Bank Promotions This Month
Delayed Maintenance Projects
What starts as an ignored roof leak can spiral into a major structural risk. HOAs frequently delay repairs due to depleted reserves or board paralysis. Florida’s Surfside condo collapse became a turning point as new laws now demand regular reserve studies to prevent those avoidable, dangerous oversights from happening again.
More From The Penny Hoarder: Budgeting 101: How to Budget Money
Legal Battles With Residents
No one buys a home expecting to fight their neighborhood board. Yet legal disputes over landscaping and unpaid dues are piling up. In California alone, HOA-related court filings have increased over the past five years. Lawsuits drain funds and often leave both sides worse off.
More From The Penny Hoarder: Our Picks for The Best Budget Apps for Couples
Discriminatory Policy Practices
Some rules sound neutral until they’re used to target certain groups. HOAs have faced federal investigations for banning cultural lawn decor and limiting who can live in a home. In 2020, the Department of Housing and Urban Development flagged a rise in Fair Housing Act violations tied to HOAs.
More From The Penny Hoarder: 5 Strategies to Consolidate Your Credit Card Debt
Unresponsive To Complaints
Emails go unanswered, security gates stay broken, and mold keeps spreading through shared walls—all met with silence. According to the Community Associations Institute, poor communication is a top cause of tension in HOAs. When trust fades, the whole community starts to break down.
More From The Penny Hoarder: What is Debt Settlement and How Does it Work?
Fines That Escalate Fast
A missed trash can pickup notice snowballs into hundreds in fines. Some HOAs apply penalties daily without warning or appeal. In Texas, one HOA fined a veteran over $10,000 for an American flag display. The issue is an unchecked escalation that feels more like punishment than correction.
More From The Penny Hoarder: Ditch Overpriced Car Insurance Now — Save $500 Today
Vendor Contracts With Kickbacks
In 2021, the Nevada Real Estate Division filed a formal complaint against board members of the Wine Ridge Estates HOA in Las Vegas for allegedly accepting bribes from vendors in exchange for contracts. The investigation uncovered financial misconduct and transparency issues, highlighting how vendor relationships can quietly undermine an entire HOA’s integrity.
More From The Penny Hoarder: Here’s How to Start Saving Money — Even If You Don’t Have Room in Your Budget
No Oversight Or Audits
Financial reports go unchecked for years in some HOAs. There’s no state-mandated audit in many places, which leaves budgets vulnerable to errors. According to the National Center for Community Association Law, fewer than 25% of HOAs undergo regular third-party audits. No oversight means no safety net for missteps or misconduct.
More From The Penny Hoarder: The 28 Best Side Hustles: Our Top Picks to Help You Make More Money
Conflicts Of Interest
Board members hiring family or presidents with vendor connections often go unnoticed until residents raise concerns. Although most states require these ties to be disclosed, enforcement is inconsistent. Without clear transparency, the board begins to feel like a private club instead of a community-focused group.
More From The Penny Hoarder: 17 Make-Your-Own-Schedule Jobs You Can Do From Home
Foreclosures Over Minor Issues
Unpaid fines or late dues can lead to foreclosure in HOA-run communities. Unlike mortgage lenders, HOAs can start foreclosure without a judge in some states. The consequences are irreversible. In Georgia, homeowners have lost properties over less than $1,000. The system allows for consequences far beyond the crime.
More From The Penny Hoarder: 22 Legit Games That Pay Real Money (2025)
Residents Leaving In Protest
When the stress outweighs the sense of community, people pack up. Some sell at a loss just to escape. A growing number of homebuyers now avoid HOA neighborhoods entirely. Real estate agents report this trend in states like Arizona and Florida. The exodus reflects something deeper: people want control over their homes.
More From The Penny Hoarder: Smarten Up, Americans. No Offense But Millions of Us Haven’t Used These Money Secrets
