15 Costly Coin Collection Mistakes To Avoid

Collecting coins isn’t just about spotting shiny treasures—it’s about dodging costly slip-ups that sneak in over time. A single mistake can drain value faster than you’d guess. Ready to protect your stash and your sanity? Let’s make your collection mistake-proof, one blunder at a time!

Cleaning Coins With Household Products

Using vinegar or baking soda might make coins look clean, but it strips away valuable patina and leaves micro-scratches. Some auction houses can also reject cleaned coins entirely. A single bad scrub can cut a coin’s worth by 90%—no exaggeration.
More From The Penny Hoarder: These Money Secrets Make You Look Rich (Without Wrecking Your Budget)

Storing Coins In PVC Holders

PVC-based holders release acid as they age, causing corrosive green slime that eats away metal surfaces. Even holders labeled “safe” can contain hidden PVC. In warmer climates, visible damage may show in less than a year and can’t be reversed.

Make money easier. Sign up for The Penny Hoarder’s newsletter today.

Ignoring Proper Humidity Control

Tossing coins into a drawer without thinking about humidity is a mistake. Moisture invites tarnish, mold and corrosion. Not all threats are blocked by sealed coin slabs. Many collectors use cigar humidors to maintain a safe sub-50% humidity level.
More From The Penny Hoarder: How to Invest with AI: Tools and Tips for 2025

Overpaying For Polished Coins

Polished coins shine, but that sparkle often hides damage. The mint’s original surface gets stripped away, killing collector value. Look for unnatural gleams or too-smooth details. Remember, true mint luster and not shine is what makes a coin worth serious money.
More From The Penny Hoarder: Here’s How to Get Cheap Auto Insurance Without Cutting Coverage

Believing Age Equals Value

Just because a coin is old doesn’t mean it’s rare. Many were mass-produced and flooded the market today. A 200-year-old coin might be worth less than a rare 1970s error. It’s not the age but the story behind the piece.
More From The Penny Hoarder: Best Cash Back Rewards Credit Cards to Earn Money While You Spend in 2025

Touching Coins With Bare Hands

Touching coins with your fingers might seem harmless, but oils from your skin trigger oxidation and leave dark, permanent marks. Just one touch can downgrade a coin’s value. That’s why collectors swear by white cotton gloves—no exceptions.
More From The Penny Hoarder: The Top 0% Interest APR Credit Cards in 2025

Forgetting To Record Provenance

A clear ownership history adds legitimacy and sparks buyer interest. Coins linked to famous collectors often sell for premiums, sometimes doubling their value. Documenting provenance is more than paperwork, as it can be a powerful tool to boost auction prices.
More From The Penny Hoarder: The 5 Top Apps for Saving Money in 2025

Not Verifying Coin Authenticity

Fake and altered coins flood online marketplaces, often fooling casual buyers. Trusted grading services like NGC and PCGS certify authenticity. Surprisingly, convincing counterfeits even appear at major coin conventions, making verification essential for every purchase.
More From The Penny Hoarder: 100+ Places That Will Give You Free Stuff on Your Birthday

Breaking Up Original Coin Sets

Separating coins from original mint packaging slashes set value, sometimes by hundreds of dollars. Complete sets prove provenance and attract more buyers. Even the envelope or certificate of authenticity can significantly boost the price collectors will pay.
More From The Penny Hoarder: How to Score the Best Cheap Tires Online and Save Big

Neglecting Coin Insurance

Without insurance, theft, fire or floods can wipe out collections instantly. Regular homeowners’ policies don’t always cover full coin values. So, specialized insurance offers peace of mind at low premiums. Surprisingly, coins in bank vaults aren’t always automatically insured.
More From The Penny Hoarder: Is Solitaire Cash Legit?

Overlooking Error Coins

Mint errors often fetch far more than regular issues, yet many collectors miss spotting them. The famous 1955 doubled die penny sold for over $100,000. Some error coins resemble damage but are actually prized rarities sought by savvy collectors.
More From The Penny Hoarder: Need Money Immediately? 6 Ways To Find Fast Cash

Misreading Coin Grading Scales

A coin’s grade—from Good to Mint State—can change its value dramatically. A single-grade jump might add hundreds of dollars. Even experts sometimes debate close grades like MS-65 and MS-66. To protect value, understanding grading nuances is vital.
More From The Penny Hoarder: MyPoints Review: Does It Really Pay and How Does It Work?

Relying Solely On Online Prices

Coin prices shift daily with market demand and metal prices. Sold auction prices give a clearer picture than active listings. Many eBay “Buy It Now” prices run well above actual sales. Regional demand differences can also cause wide price swings.
More From The Penny Hoarder: How to Access Your Paycheck Early: 4 Reliable Options

Displaying Coins In Direct Sunlight

UV rays fade a coin’s toning and damage its packaging, while heat warps plastic holders and exposes coins to dirt. In fact, months of sunlight can degrade coin quality. Protecting coins from UV exposure keeps their surfaces and value intact longer.
More From The Penny Hoarder: 6 Free Budgeting Templates To Help You Save In 2025

Focusing Only On U.S. Coins

Limiting your collection to U.S. coins misses out on unique and undervalued international rarities. Some Canadian coins outperform American ones in value. Worldwide collectors heavily influence prices at online auctions, making global coins a hidden goldmine.
More From The Penny Hoarder: Our Picks for The Best Savings Accounts for This Month