You’re Wasting Your Money on Cage-Free Eggs. Here’s What to Buy Instead
Organic? Cage-free? Brown? Whatever’s cheapest?
I’m getting overwhelmed just thinking about it.
If you’re like me, you want to get the best product for both your body and budget — while also hopefully not supporting a business that leaves its beakless birds in a tiny cage.
Does that even exist? And if it does, how can you wade through a carton’s many labels to find it?
It’s time to demystify the world of eggs… and explain why those cage-free eggs probably aren’t worth the money.
What Those Labels on Egg Cartons Actually Mean
First off, note this: “95% of eggs in the U.S. come from chickens raised in something called battery cages,” reports NPR.
“As many as 100,000 birds can be confined in a single warehouse, each bird with less than 67 square inches… to call its own,” explains Mother Earth News.
To put it in perspective, that’s an area a little smaller than a MacBook.
Unable to move or spread their wings, this is where the chickens will spend their entire lives.
So. That’s our baseline.
Now, let’s dive into what all those extra labels actually mean…
We’ve been trained to believe brown food is healthier than white food (think: whole grain bread, brown rice), so we automatically assume brown eggs must be healthier, too.
Unfortunately, that’s not the case.
All-Natural / Farm Fresh / Hormone-Free
These terms are meaningless.
Again, this sounds good — but it’s not, because chickens are omnivores.
Therefore, “vegetarian” birds are force-fed an unnatural diet that’s bad for their health.
“Chickens are the furthest thing from vegetarians,” one farmer told The Washington Post. “That advertising is ridiculous. It’s like people going to the zoo and saying they only want to see the vegetarian tiger.”
Another writes: “The label ‘vegetarian fed’ is a warning sign that the poultry did not get to spend any time on pasture being happy birds.”
Ready for a surprise (and not the good kind)? Cage-free isn’t what it’s cracked up to be.
To help clarify things, I hopped on the phone with Mark Kastel, founder of the Cornucopia Institute, an organization that researches and advocates sustainable agricultural policy.
Consumers have a vision that cage-free chickens are out on “these bucolic pastures” and “have lots of room to move around,” he explains.
“That’s just not accurate.”
Instead of cages, these chickens are packed by the thousands into multi-level aviaries… and they still never get to see the outdoors.
Some experts think it’s a step in the right direction, since the birds can exhibit natural behaviors like spreading their wings, walking and nesting. (Walking! What a treat!)
But others believe that, due to poor indoor air quality, cannibalism and higher mortality rates, it’s not really any better for the chickens.
One thing everyone agrees on? Cage-free operations cost 36% more to operate, a cost that’s passed on to you.
With that in mind, do you think they’re worth the cost? I don’t, and neither do the experts.
When I asked Kastel if cage-free eggs were a waste of money, his answer was a quick “Yes.”
“If people are buying cage free because they think they’re making a statement about humane animal practices,” he says, “they’re getting shortchanged.”
All right, we’re getting closer.
In theory, free-range should mean chickens wandering around a beautiful field; in reality, though, the USDA just mandates these chickens “have access to the outdoors.”
But access to the outdoors is different than actually going outdoors, and Kastel says: “The term ‘free-range’ is very poorly regulated.”
He calls this deceitful labeling “farming by press release,” and says a company’s “marketing rhetoric might talk about ‘free-range’ — but when we go to the farm, there aren’t any birds outside.”
That’s because “access,” according to his interview with NPR, typically consists of “a few small doors that lead to a screened-in porch with cement, dirt or a modicum of grass.”
And, thanks to industrial fans sucking ammonia out of the building, these doorways are plagued by “hurricane winds,” which the chickens have no desire to walk through.
Ugh, fooled again!
Ah, organic. Slap this seven-letter word on anything, and people will pay more for it.
Organic eggs must come from “uncaged hens that are free to roam in their houses and have access to the outdoors,” according to the USDA.
“The hens are fed an organic diet of feed produced without conventional pesticides or fertilizers.”
Though you can feel sure about these chickens’ diets, their access to the outdoors is also iffy, according to Kastel.
So, it’s a good starting point, but not all you should be looking for.
At the moment, you can usually trust this label to mean what you think it means: chickens with plenty of time to play outside.
But it’s important to note this term is NOT regulated by the FDA, and conventional egg farmers could hijack it at any point.
And even pastured chickens are raised with a variety of standards. Many farms, for example, still engage in beak-cutting and the culling of male chicks.
To figure out which farms are best, I highly recommend Cornucopia’s egg-cellent (sorry, I couldn’t resist) organic egg scorecard, which took six years to produce and ranks 136 egg producers on 28 different criteria.
Pasture-raised hens, for the most part, are actually happy and healthy. Which means they’re better for you, too.
According to a study by Mother Earth News, here’s how pasture-raised eggs compare to commercial eggs:
- One-third less cholesterol
- One-quarter less saturated fat
- Two-thirds more vitamin A
- Twice as many omega-3 fatty acids
- Three times as much vitamin E
- Seven times as much beta carotene
Here’s a Simple Summary
So, Which Eggs Should I Buy?
Now that we’ve demystified egg labeling, one question remains: Which eggs should I buy?
My simple answer: Do everything you can to buy pasture-raised eggs.
I know they’re expensive, but they’re yummier, richer in nutrients and way better for the chickens who lay them. In my opinion, they’re absolutely worth the price.
And, as Kastel points out, “Food is the absolute foundation for good health.” It’ll pay off in the end.
To cut back on your grocery bill — and make room in your budget for the pricier eggs — you can clip coupons or try these crazy strategies. I also use Ibotta, an app that often offers cash-back rebates on eggs.
(Don’t forget to check Cornucopia’s egg scorecard before selecting a brand!)
Can’t afford pastured eggs? Then just buy the cheapest ones you can find.
If you’re on a really tight budget, it’s not worth spending extra money on the middle-of-the-road cage-free or free-range options, because they’re not much better for anyone (or any chicken) involved.
Then, down the road, hopefully you’ll be able to afford the good kind.
But the best solution? For your health and budget — and the happiness of both you and the birds?
When I buy a house someday, that’s the first thing I’m going to do.
Your Turn: What kind of eggs do you buy? Do you get confused at the grocery store?
Susan Shain, senior writer for The Penny Hoarder, is always seeking adventure on a budget. Visit her blog at susanshain.com, or say hi on Twitter @susan_shain.
The Penny Hoarder Promise: We provide accurate, reliable information. Here’s why you can trust us and how we make money.